The Nebulous Kingdom

In a world of complex systems

12/19/2011

Comments

 
http://www.wired.com/magazine/2011/12/ff_causation/all/1

I saw this article right after I checked my 23andme health updates based on my genome scan.  The juxtaposition of the two was striking.

Excerpts:
"There was a vast amount of research behind Kindler’s bold proclamations. The  cholesterol pathway is one of the best-understood biological feedback systems in the human body...Furthermore, torcetrapib had already undergone a small clinical trial, which showed that the drug could  increase HDL and decrease LDL. Kindler told his investors that, by the second half of 2007, Pfizer would begin applying for approval from the FDA. The success of the drug seemed like a sure thing.

 And then, just two days later, on December 2, 2006, Pfizer issued a stunning announcement: The torcetrapib Phase III clinical trial was being terminated. Although the compound was supposed to prevent heart disease, it was actually triggering higher rates of chest pain and heart failure and a 60 percent increase in overall mortality. The drug appeared to be killing people.

 That week, Pfizer’s value plummeted by $21 billion."

"This assumption—that understanding a system’s constituent parts means we also understand the causes within the system—is not limited to the pharmaceutical industry or even to biology. It defines modern science. In general, we believe that the so-called problem of causation can be cured by more information, by our ceaseless accumulation of facts. Scientists refer to this process as reductionism. By breaking down a process, we can see how everything fits together"

"The problem with this assumption, however, is that causes are a strange kind of knowledge. This was first pointed out by David Hume, the 18th-century Scottish philosopher. Hume realized that, although people talk about causes as if they are real facts—tangible things that can be discovered—they’re actually not at all factual. Instead, Hume said, every cause is just a slippery story, a catchy conjecture, a “lively conception produced by habit"...a cause is not a fact—it’s a fiction that helps us make sense of facts"

"Though scientists constantly remind themselves that mere correlation is
not causation, if a correlation is clear and consistent, then they typically assume a cause has been found—that there really is some invisible association between the measurements."


It is interesting how we seem to know things - like "correlation does not imply causation" or "past performance is not an indication of future results" - and ignore them so often and readily within the disciplines that own these mantras.  It's at the same time silly and understandable - we don't have any better tools to make sense of the world.  But at least we should admit that to ourselves.

--

So I checked my 23andme updates today - I get regular messages from the company with new information on my genome scan based on new studies.  Most disease risk lines come back with typical odds - I'm depressingly normal.

Today I have a red line for Primary Biliary Cirrhosis.  It seems I have a 1.72x higher risk of contracting this form of cirrhosis than the average person, based on established research (meaning multiple studies with 750+ participants).  Nearly twice the risk - that's not good, right? 

Well, it turns out that it's not good but it's not really that bad either.  Apparently the average person has a 0.3% risk while I have a 0.6% risk.  It's not going to rock my life in any meaningful way, at least pre-diagnosis.

It does beg the question - is more information always better?  I have tended to think yes in the past but the outcomes aren't always better when you know more.  But then again, if information is available and curated, then someone needs to play curator.  I don't know if I trust anyone else to play curator for me, and playing curator for myself obviates the question.  And if we believe that more information tends to converge to the truth, perhaps we should just figure out how to deal with the information we receive rather than avoid it altogether.

Comments
    Picture

    Author

    I'm interested in uncertainty, time, trust, consistency, strategy, economics, empathy, philosophy, education, technology, story-telling, and fractals.
    Contact

    Archives

    May 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    June 2015
    January 2015
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009

    RSS Feed


    My Favorite Curators


    Email newsletters

    Edge.org
    John Mauldin
    STRATFOR
    Futurity.org
    BPS Research Digest
    Domain-B.com
    FORA.tv
    PopTech!
    PIMCO Investment Outlooks
    GMO Client Reports
    Big Think
    Commonwealth Club
    Someecards.com
    MRN Research Papers
    Chicago Booth eNewsletters
    McKinsey Quarterly
    Boldtype / Artkrush
    Singularity University
    Charlie Rose
    The Aspen Institute


    Feeds

    WNYC
    Radiolab

    This American Life
    Freakonomics Radio
    The Moth
    Chicago Booth Podcast
    The Atlantic Council
    The Memory Palace
    TED.com
    Foreign Affairs
    The Ideas Project
    Long Now Foundation
    The School of Life
    Letters of Note

    Periodicals

    The Economist
    The Wall Street Journal
    The New Yorker
    The New York Times
    Wired Magazine
    The Atlantic

    Other Websites

    Oaktree Capital Memos
    LSE Public Lectures
    Bubblegeneration
    Becker-Posner Blog
    Eric Von Hippel
    NetAge
    John Seely Brown
    Malcolm Gladwell
    John Hagel
    HBR – The Big Shift
    LookBook.nu
    Robert Shiller
    Paul Graham
    Frontline PBS
    Royal Society for the Arts
    Blake Masters

    Humor

    Best of Craigslist
    Texts from Last Night
    FMyLIfe
    MyLifeisAverage
    Lamebook
    The Onion


    Categories

    All